"Detective Sherdil," starring Diljit Dosanjh, has arrived, and reviews are pouring in, painting a varied picture of this mystery comedy. Directed by Ravi Chhabriya, the film attempts to blend humor and suspense in a whodunit setting, but the execution seems to have divided critics.
Several reviews highlight Dosanjh's performance as Detective Sherdil, a quirky character who fancies himself a blend of Sherlock Holmes, Byomkesh Bakshi, and Karamchand. However, some critics feel that Dosanjh's portrayal falls flat, with an "annoying smile" and a reliance on a mouth organ that feels more like a gimmick than a genuine character trait. Others praise Dosanjh for his charm and comedic timing, noting that he was well-cast.
The film's plot revolves around the murder of a wealthy businessman, Pankage Bhatti, leading Detective Sherdil to investigate a cast of suspicious family members and acquaintances. While the setup has potential, several reviews point out that the screenplay is riddled with loopholes and predictable twists. Some viewers may find themselves guessing the culprit early on, diminishing the suspense. The script, according to one review, "prefers flamboyance over function," sacrificing a compelling narrative for stylish visuals.
Visually, "Detective Sherdil" has received mixed reactions. Some appreciate the film's aesthetic, with its European architecture and well-manicured sets. However, others feel that the direction is unsure, with scenes that drag on and a climax that feels unearned. The film's attempts at humor are also a point of contention, with some finding them misplaced and disruptive to the suspense.
The supporting cast includes Diana Penty, Boman Irani, Ratna Pathak Shah, Sumeet Vyas, Banita Sandhu, and Chunky Panday. While some performances are praised, particularly Banita Sandhu's portrayal of a deaf and mute character, others are described as one-dimensional or underutilized. Ratna Pathak Shah, for instance, is said to have never quite shed her "Maya Sarabhai aura," while Chunky Panday's role is considered too small.
Overall, "Detective Sherdil" appears to be a mixed bag. While Diljit Dosanjh's charisma and the film's stylish presentation may appeal to some viewers, others may find the plot predictable, the humor forced, and the characters underdeveloped. Several critics suggest that the film suffers from "terminal self-indulgence," prioritizing style over substance. Whether "Detective Sherdil" is a must-watch or a case best left unsolved seems to depend on individual taste and expectations.
